Aug 7, 2025
Simon Cooper

Why Not Everything You Toss in the Blue Bin Actually Gets Recycled

Think everything in your blue bin gets recycled? Think again. Learn why municipal recycling often fails—and how Nada ensures your used brush heads are 100% commercially recycled through our closed-loop take-back program.

Plastic bottles

Most of us believe that placing items into our blue box means they’ll be recycled. In reality, municipal recycling programs face systemic challenges that mean a surprisingly large share of that waste doesn’t actually get recycled.

Contamination and “Wish‑cycling”

  • Wish‑cycling—the practice of tossing questionable items into recycling, hoping they’ll be accepted—is widespread and harmful. When non‑recyclable items end up in the recycling stream, they often contaminate entire batches, causing them to be rejected and sent to landfill.

  • Food residue, greasy pizza boxes, plastic bags, mixed materials, or small pieces can all pollute loads, raising costs and reducing the volume of truly recyclable materials.

 Inconsistent Rules Across Regions

  • Recycling rules vary dramatically by municipality—even neighbouring suburbs may accept different plastics or packaging. What’s recyclable in one city might require landfill in another. This inconsistency feeds confusion, uncertainty, and mistakes by residents

Low Recycling Rates and Economic Strain

  • Nationally, only around 32 % of municipal solid waste in the U.S. is recycled or composted.

  • Plastic performs worse: only about 13–14 % of plastic containers and packaging were recycled; much is incinerated or landfilled.

  • At best, only 5–9 % of plastic placed in recycling bins ends up being actually recycled, due to contamination. 

 Emerging Concerns: Microplastics and Leakage

  • The recycling process is not completely benign: washing recyclable plastics can release microplastics into wastewater and air, affecting communities and workers health.

  • Overall, the U.S. recycling system “leaks”—with materials diverted to landfill despite being labelled recyclable—largely due to contamination, poorly sorted streams, or low-value materials.

What You Can Do: Recycle Better.

  • Learn your local rules and stick to items that are accepted and clean—no leftover food, grease, or non-recyclable plastics.

  • Resist wish‑cycling—even if an item “might be recyclable,” if you’re unsure, don’t risk contaminating the rest.

  • Support Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) policies that shift the cost of recycling to manufacturers—making packaging design and recyclability matter again.

Exactly What Happens—and Doesn’t Happen—with Your Blue Box

Despite good intentions, items in your recycling bin often:

  • Are sorted out and landfilled due to contamination.

  • Remain unrecycled due to low market demand or no processing capacity.

  • Break or gum up machinery, prompting facilities to discard entire loads—especially plastic bags or film.

So even if something seems recyclable in theory, it may not make it through the system. Recycling isn't magic—it requires proper sorting, demand, and infrastructure.

How Nada Does Recycling Differently: 100 % Commercial Recycling of Brush Heads

This is where Nada’s brush head take-back program stands above curbside recycling. 

Every Nada toothbrush order includes a pre-addressed envelope—you collect your worn brush heads, seal them up, and mail them back to Nada 

What Happens Next?

  • Nada sends the used brush heads to TerraCycle, a certified commercial recycling partner.

  • Bristles are separated from plastic; both are processed into plastic pellets.

  • These pellets are then sold for use in new products, completing a closed commercial recycling loop.

That means Nada brush heads are 100% recycled—not contaminated, not downcycled or discarded. Unlike municipal recycling, Nada controls the full chain—from pickup to reuse.

Why That Matters

  1. No contamination risk—you send only brush heads back, so they're clean and deterministic for recycling.

  2. Guaranteed processing—Nada pays for commercial recycling and knows exactly where the materials go.

  3. Circularity at work—the plastic from brush heads becomes new material for other uses, closing the loop.

A Better Blue Box and Beyond

Municipal recycling has its place, but it's fundamentally flawed:

  • Not everything you toss gets recycled.

  • Contamination, inconsistent rules, weak economics, and poor infrastructure hinder success.

  • And in many cases, recycling creates more hidden environmental harm, like microplastic release or greenhouse gas emissions.

That’s why specialized programs like Nada’s are powerful:

  • You know what gets recycled and how.

  • You avoid loss from contamination.

  • You help build a truly circular economy, one closed‑loop product at a time.

In Summary

Municipal recycling is under strain: inconsistent standards, wish‑cycling, contaminated streams, and low recovery rates mean much of what’s collected ends up in landfill or worse. Plastic is particularly vulnerable—with only single‑digit recycling rates for many types.

Every time you mail your used brush heads to Nada, you're actively closing the loop—not waiting for uncertain municipal processes, but taking ownership of recycling success.

By using Nada, you’re part of the solution—not just recycling more, but recycling right.

Join the movement to ditch disposables, get your Nada toothbrush here.

Updated August 07, 2025

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.